The First Annual Thomistic Bioethics Colloquium: Towards a Thomistic Understanding of Death in the Clinical Setting

June 6, 2025

Human death, defined as the moment when the soul departs from the body, is a single event that no empiric approach can directly identify. Clinical determinations of death have traditionally relied on signs and parameters to ascertain that death has already occurred. In recent decades, developments in life-sustaining medical interventions and resuscitation techniques have complicated determinations of death, prompting additional approaches beyond those based on cardiopulmonary function to include the neurological determination of death—often referred to as “brain death.” Ongoing clinical and ethical controversies about how precisely to determine when death has occurred call attention to the natural tensions and overlap between philosophical and scientific understandings of death. This colloquium aims to work towards consensus in articulating a more robust metaphysical understanding of death—presupposing a Thomistic-Aristotelian hylomorphic framework—that will aid ongoing conversations about clinical approaches to determining death.

Download the Colloquium Summary Statement

Conferences will be published as a special issue of Nova et Vetera. Read conference papers below.

A Thomistic Reappraisal of Novel Accounts for What Constitutes Death in the Clinical Setting. Sr. Mary Diana Dreger, OP MD, and Sr. Elinor Gardner, OP PhD.
download preprint

Substance and Organism as a Whole: A Correlation between Aristotelian-Thomistic Metaphysics and Contemporary Holistic Biophilosophy. Doyen Nguyen, MD STD
download preprint

Neither Brain Life nor Brain Death: A Systems Hylomorphic Account for the Beginning and End of Life. Fr. Nicanor Austriaco, OP STD PhD
coming soon

Unity, Integration, or Wholeness? Part-whole causality in Patients Receiving Life-sustaining Interventions. Cody Feikles, PhD(c) HEC-C and Fr. Columba Thomas, OP MD
coming soon

Thomistic Metaphysics and the Irreversibility of Death. Catherine Nolan, PhD
coming soon

An Emerging Thomistic Metaphysical Framework for Death in the Clinical Setting: Points of Consensus and Opportunities for Dialogue. Fr. Columba Thomas, OP MD
coming soon

Mark your calendars for the Second Annual Thomistic Bioethics Conference: Anointing of the Sick in its Pastoral, Theological, and Historical Dimensions

May 29th 2026.